Motorcycle Myth #2 Summoning the gods of combustion speed

Motorcycle Myth #2 Summoning the gods of combustion speed

Myth # 2 Octane boosters, and combustion speed

It’s common practice for people to summon the gods of combustion speed to try and explain the magic powers of toluene, acetone and any number of Home Depot speed secrets they are trying to foist off on an unknowing audience. They’ll tell you that these paint store solvents raise the octane of the fuel and as a result slow down combustion and fend off detonation as a result. It’s just more pseudo-science BS from people who would have done well to pay more attention in Chemistry 101 in high school. Real combustion events follow the real laws of chemistry, and while it’s a pretty complex set of interactions there are a few things that are easy to explain and understand.

It's a commonly held misconception that higher Octane fuel slows down the flame speed, which keeps the engine from knocking. What a load of crap.
A fuel's laminar Flame speed (basically fuel burning without the influence of combustion swirl or tumble) is a function of fuel chemistry (specifically Hydrogen/Carbon ratio), not the Octane rating.

The Hydrogen/Carbon make up of the fuel will determine it’s flame speed and the energy release whether it's a high-octane fuel or not. You can have fast and slow burning high octane fuels, but in most cases the differences are so slight as to not be an issue.

The heat of combustion at a simple level is basically a function of combustion efficiency and the calorific (energy) value of a fuel. There isn't a lot of energy difference between most conventional fuels, but combustion efficiency can sometimes be improved with race fuels so a bit more heat release is possible. Overall it's pretty much a wash in most cases though.

In other words, you aren't going to change the energy release or the speed of combustion in any significant way by switching from 87 to 110 octane gasoline, or anything in between . If you lose or gain power by switching fuels there are other things at work.

The way octane influences knock has to do with the way fuel is burned (well it’s really REACTED in the chamber) in the combustion chamber. The components in higher-octane fuels are less likely to have weak molecular bonds that can break easily and form active radicals. Higher-octane fuel is just made up of components that are (for lack of a better term) stouter under high temperatures and high cylinder pressures. Things like our long lost friend lead and metallic additives like MMT (common in octane boosters) tend to work as an anti-catalyst and block the formation of the active radicals that lead to auto-ignition of the fuel and ultimately detonation. The longer it takes to react all the fuel the greater the chances are that heat will accelerate the reactions beyond what the fuel components can bear. The idea that purposely SLOWING things down in the chamber is somehow beneficial in light of the reactions taking place is pretty funny really

Heat , pressure, and time tend to be the driving force in all of this. The more heat and pressure you subject the fuel to and the longer you keep the temps elevated the better and more stable the fuel you need . That's why engines that run at high rpm and have small bores can run very low octane fuels even with high compression ratios.

It's just simple chemistry really. If you look at the chemistry of explosives you can see a lot of similar reactions taking place, and it can give you some real insights into what's happening inside the combustion chamber when things go wrong. It's a fine line between engine tuner and explosives engineer.
 

Rich Rohrich

Moderator / BioHazard
LIFETIME SPONSOR
Jul 27, 1999
22,838
16,902
Chicago
Now that the season is in full swing lets push a few threads back to the top and see if people want to contribute to the discussion.
 

Rich Rohrich

Moderator / BioHazard
LIFETIME SPONSOR
Jul 27, 1999
22,838
16,902
Chicago
Bump
 

jaguar

~SPONSOR~
Jul 29, 2000
1,501
82
South America
OK now that you've made it clear that high octane doesn't slow down the burn, can you answer if there is a general rule to go by when selecting a fuel if we want to increase or slow down the combustion rate? (I mean something that can be found out about a fuel. Saying it has to do with the hydrogen/carbon ratio is of zero usefulness to me unless there is a way to know what each fuels ratio is.)
 

Rich Rohrich

Moderator / BioHazard
LIFETIME SPONSOR
Jul 27, 1999
22,838
16,902
Chicago
First of all, I can't think of any situation where slowing down the combustion rate would be a good idea. The longer the reaction takes the more time the mixture is exposed to heat and pressure which brings it closer to the fuels auto-ignition threshold.

Based on what I know about the readily available legal hydrocarbon based fuels and additives in the US, there is nothing you can do to significantly impact the speed of combustion with the fuel alone. Carcinogenic additives like propylene oxide have been tried in the past to speed up reactions and increase horsepower in some applications but the associated problems far outweighed any advantages gained.

Combustion speed comes from mechanical design considerations and as was pointed out by another post, the homogenization or uniformity of the mixture. A uniformly mixed charge with a minimum of already burned charge left over from the previous cycle makes a huge difference in the combustion speed. You're a two-stroke guy so I know you're likely familiar with the difference in the octane requirement of an engine that you've gotten the transfers and scavenging dialed in on versus one that's a bit off. When the scavenging is bad the combustion speed slows down and the knock free octane requirement goes up.


The paper cited below is four-stroke related but it has information that is universally valuable. I read it in high school when it first came out and it helped me understand a lot about the combustion process and how fuel plays a significant role. It's worth a read for those who want more details.


Research and Development of High-Speed, High-Performance, Small Displacement Honda Engines​

SAE paper # 700122​

Abstract : Honda has produced high-speed, high-performance, 4-stroke cycle gasoline engines by applying advanced technology gained through the design and development of motorcycles and automobiles for Grand Prix racing. Some of Honda's racing engines attained performance as high as 260 bhp/liter or nearly 4.3 bhp/cu in. at speeds of up to 25,000 rpm. This paper describes our technical approach for optimizing combustion efficiency, volumetric efficiency, and mechanical efficiency-the keys to high-speed, high-performance engines.
 
Top Bottom