EngineIce? or Engine Hotter
I don't see how this EngineIce stuff can improve cooling. I work in the HVAC industry (heating, ventilation, air-conditioning) and know a little about the heat transfer of liquids.
Before reading on, please remember the following: The environmental and safety benefits are great reasons to use propylene glycol instead of ethylene glycol. For sure, propylene glycol is much, much safer for kids, pets, and the environment.
EngineIce provides information that they use propylene glycol in deionized water and I am not sure what else - in my opinion, they are not real clear about anything else that is in it. Going by the -27 degF freeze protection they show, in my opinion, they are probably about 50/50 with the DI water, depending on what else is in it.
Well, I think IF the EngineIce coolant does, in fact, show a cooler temperature than regular coolant, then I think the actual engine parts themselves must be holding the heat and get hotter. Why do I think this, because I don't see how EngineIce can transfer heat as well as normal coolant? Why would I think this? Well, read on:
Its fairly common knowledge in HVAC that straight water has the best heat transfer characteristics, 50/50 ethylene glycol/water is next, and 50/50 propylene glycol/water has the worst heat transfer characteristics of the 3. As most of you know, the automotive anti-freeze you buy at the store is ethylene glycol (except for that one "pet safe" brand, I think its called Sierra, which is propylene glycol).
Numbers wise, at 180 degF, the thermal conductivity of 50/50 propylene glycol/water is around 7% LESS (worse) than the thermal conductivity of 50/50 ethylene glycol/water and about 43% LESS (worse) than that of straight water. Thats probably why all the automakers put ethylene glycol in cars - it works better thermally. I would think that if you want the actual engine parts themselves to run cooler and not just have a cooler liquid temperature, that you would want the fluid with the best heat transfer characteristics in the cooling system. I guess the real test would be to measure the actual exterior cylinder wall and exterior head temperature along with the coolant temp before and after putting in the EngineIce. A guy could maybe use one of those handheld electronic infrared HVAC surface temp measurement devices to do this.
Maxima's Coolanol, on the other hand, is 50/50 ethylene glycol in deionized water. I would think that putting Redline's WaterWetter in the Coolanol or in your own 33% ethylene glycol / 66% water mix would be a better way to go (or even a 25/75 mix). WaterWetter actually improves the heat transfer characteristics of a system rather than making them worse, plus the lower ethylene glycol percentage (and therefore increased water) will also help a bunch. I know the 33/66 or 25/75 mix won't offer the same freeze (or boil over) protection as a 50/50 mix, but most of us can probably live with, and adjust for that. I guess you could also add more water to the Coolanol if you wanted to go the premium product route but wanted less than a 50/50 mix.
Please Note: If you think you won't remember to add more glycol for the wintertime or your bike isn't go to be kept where it will never freeze, then, as you know, don't mess with going with less than 50% ethylene or propylene glycol in water.
Also please note: Remember, besides freezing sooner, there is another trade-off in running less ethylene or propylene glycol since the higher percentage of it you have, then the higher the boiling point of your coolant is.
The whole reason I started looking at increasing my bike's cooling performance is because when I go slow in very tight stuff or when climbing hills for a while, it seems like my bike gets a very slight low rpm detonation noise which goes away once I speed up and get some airflow through the radiator again. I know it will always eventually get hot when you go slow, but this cooling system performance improver stuff may slow down the process.
What do you guys think about all this? There is some good info about cooling systems under the WaterWetter technical info link at RedlineOil (www.redlineoil.com) and here are the Coolanol (www.maximausa.com) and EngineIce (www.cyclelogic.cc) links.
I repeat: If you think you won't remember to add more glycol for the wintertime or your bike isn't go to be kept where it will never freeze, then, as you know, don't mess with going with less than 50% ethylene or propylene glycol in water.
I have noticed some other things that appear "funny" in the EngineIce FAQ's (FAQ shown below).
**********************************************************************************
What about performance?
Engine Ice Hi-Performance Coolant tm uses propylene glycol, which has been proven to eliminate water pump gasket and seal failures. It has also been proven in high load, high stress conditions to run 10oC (50oF) cooler than standard coolants.
***********************************************************************************
While a temperature of 10 degC does correspond to 50 degF, a 10 degC change (change as indicated by the word "cooler") in temp does not correspond to a 50degF change in temp. For example, a temp drop from 93 degC down to 83 degC equates to 200 degF dropping down to 182 degF or an 18 degF drop. In my opinion, that type of reference they use is misleading but I still can't believe it would even drop it 18 degF .
Also, take a look at this FAQ (below) that is directly above the "What about performance?" FAQ.
*******************************************************************************
OK, so what. I don't care if bursts into flames when I take it out. Does it work, is it cooler?
If it didn't run cooler, why bother right? Absolutely! Engine Ice Hi-Performance Coolant tm has undergone extensive testing in the extreme heat and humidity of Southern Florida. Tests have proven to reduce operating race temperatures by as much as 50oF in some situations. This is why many champions and race teams have chosen to use Engine Ice Hi-Performance Coolant TM
*******************************************************************************
In this FAQ , they use the 50 DegF reference on its own, meaning a 50 degF drop in coolant temp. In my opinion, common sense tells ya that a 50 degF drop in coolant temp due to using this stuff could just be a special situation. Is it a 10 degC drop (equates to a 18 degF drop) or a 50 degF drop?
I don't see how this EngineIce stuff can improve cooling. I work in the HVAC industry (heating, ventilation, air-conditioning) and know a little about the heat transfer of liquids.
Before reading on, please remember the following: The environmental and safety benefits are great reasons to use propylene glycol instead of ethylene glycol. For sure, propylene glycol is much, much safer for kids, pets, and the environment.
EngineIce provides information that they use propylene glycol in deionized water and I am not sure what else - in my opinion, they are not real clear about anything else that is in it. Going by the -27 degF freeze protection they show, in my opinion, they are probably about 50/50 with the DI water, depending on what else is in it.
Well, I think IF the EngineIce coolant does, in fact, show a cooler temperature than regular coolant, then I think the actual engine parts themselves must be holding the heat and get hotter. Why do I think this, because I don't see how EngineIce can transfer heat as well as normal coolant? Why would I think this? Well, read on:
Its fairly common knowledge in HVAC that straight water has the best heat transfer characteristics, 50/50 ethylene glycol/water is next, and 50/50 propylene glycol/water has the worst heat transfer characteristics of the 3. As most of you know, the automotive anti-freeze you buy at the store is ethylene glycol (except for that one "pet safe" brand, I think its called Sierra, which is propylene glycol).
Numbers wise, at 180 degF, the thermal conductivity of 50/50 propylene glycol/water is around 7% LESS (worse) than the thermal conductivity of 50/50 ethylene glycol/water and about 43% LESS (worse) than that of straight water. Thats probably why all the automakers put ethylene glycol in cars - it works better thermally. I would think that if you want the actual engine parts themselves to run cooler and not just have a cooler liquid temperature, that you would want the fluid with the best heat transfer characteristics in the cooling system. I guess the real test would be to measure the actual exterior cylinder wall and exterior head temperature along with the coolant temp before and after putting in the EngineIce. A guy could maybe use one of those handheld electronic infrared HVAC surface temp measurement devices to do this.
Maxima's Coolanol, on the other hand, is 50/50 ethylene glycol in deionized water. I would think that putting Redline's WaterWetter in the Coolanol or in your own 33% ethylene glycol / 66% water mix would be a better way to go (or even a 25/75 mix). WaterWetter actually improves the heat transfer characteristics of a system rather than making them worse, plus the lower ethylene glycol percentage (and therefore increased water) will also help a bunch. I know the 33/66 or 25/75 mix won't offer the same freeze (or boil over) protection as a 50/50 mix, but most of us can probably live with, and adjust for that. I guess you could also add more water to the Coolanol if you wanted to go the premium product route but wanted less than a 50/50 mix.
Please Note: If you think you won't remember to add more glycol for the wintertime or your bike isn't go to be kept where it will never freeze, then, as you know, don't mess with going with less than 50% ethylene or propylene glycol in water.
Also please note: Remember, besides freezing sooner, there is another trade-off in running less ethylene or propylene glycol since the higher percentage of it you have, then the higher the boiling point of your coolant is.
The whole reason I started looking at increasing my bike's cooling performance is because when I go slow in very tight stuff or when climbing hills for a while, it seems like my bike gets a very slight low rpm detonation noise which goes away once I speed up and get some airflow through the radiator again. I know it will always eventually get hot when you go slow, but this cooling system performance improver stuff may slow down the process.
What do you guys think about all this? There is some good info about cooling systems under the WaterWetter technical info link at RedlineOil (www.redlineoil.com) and here are the Coolanol (www.maximausa.com) and EngineIce (www.cyclelogic.cc) links.
I repeat: If you think you won't remember to add more glycol for the wintertime or your bike isn't go to be kept where it will never freeze, then, as you know, don't mess with going with less than 50% ethylene or propylene glycol in water.
I have noticed some other things that appear "funny" in the EngineIce FAQ's (FAQ shown below).
**********************************************************************************
What about performance?
Engine Ice Hi-Performance Coolant tm uses propylene glycol, which has been proven to eliminate water pump gasket and seal failures. It has also been proven in high load, high stress conditions to run 10oC (50oF) cooler than standard coolants.
***********************************************************************************
While a temperature of 10 degC does correspond to 50 degF, a 10 degC change (change as indicated by the word "cooler") in temp does not correspond to a 50degF change in temp. For example, a temp drop from 93 degC down to 83 degC equates to 200 degF dropping down to 182 degF or an 18 degF drop. In my opinion, that type of reference they use is misleading but I still can't believe it would even drop it 18 degF .
Also, take a look at this FAQ (below) that is directly above the "What about performance?" FAQ.
*******************************************************************************
OK, so what. I don't care if bursts into flames when I take it out. Does it work, is it cooler?
If it didn't run cooler, why bother right? Absolutely! Engine Ice Hi-Performance Coolant tm has undergone extensive testing in the extreme heat and humidity of Southern Florida. Tests have proven to reduce operating race temperatures by as much as 50oF in some situations. This is why many champions and race teams have chosen to use Engine Ice Hi-Performance Coolant TM
*******************************************************************************
In this FAQ , they use the 50 DegF reference on its own, meaning a 50 degF drop in coolant temp. In my opinion, common sense tells ya that a 50 degF drop in coolant temp due to using this stuff could just be a special situation. Is it a 10 degC drop (equates to a 18 degF drop) or a 50 degF drop?
Last edited: