American Captured in Afgahnastan

[justql]

Did anyone else hear that an American was captured in Afgahnaatan? HE WAS FIGHTING WITH THE TALIBAN. What should be done with the guy. Is he a prisoner of war, due the rules of geneva. Or is he a traitor, due death?

 

[fmfkx125372]

I heard about that too...

He's a traitor...HANG HIM

 

[ride_red_15]

hang the ******* in my opinion

 

[spanky250]

Originally posted by fmfkx125372
I heard about that too...

He's a traitor...HANG HIM

He is well on his way to becoming very wealthy if he plays the media right. All he has to do is use the "Patty Hurst" defense, and the book and movie deals will start rolling in.

Hang him? You mean like they did Jane Fonda? Fat chance...

 

[gibbs_6]

Thats a tough one.:think :eek:Hang him.:scream: :) :debil:

 

[Gary B.]

I think we need to uphold his rights, make sure he is not a victim of bad parenting or society, give him a fair trial, THEN LINE HIM AND ANY OTHERS LIKE HIM AGAINST THE WALL AND SHOOT THEM AS THE TRAITORS THEY ARE!!!!!!!!:p :p :p

 

[MX GZR]

He's NOT an American. He ceased to be an American when he picked up a gun for the Taliban. Let the military court try him as a war criminal then shoot him!

 

[justql]

The thing is if he's not American, he can't be executed. If he's American.....I don't know what legally can happen.

 

[Kawidude]

If he is still considered an American and he raised a weapon against our own military, I believe he can be charged with treason. Isn't treason punishable by death?

 

[JeffK]

'I am an American.'

I can't believe this littler f*&^er has the balls to even say those words!!! Does he really consider himself to still be a citizen of our country???? I say we bury him up to his head in my front yard and let me get out my John Deere!!!!!! Brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrkachunkrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr .. End of story.

Jeff

 

[bwalker]

They had a couple of lawyers on Fox news last night that said he should be tried by a civillian court for sedition. Sedition was the crime the Rosenburg's where executed for.

 

[Jonala]

He should be returned to any village that he may have been assigned to. Then let the villagers do what ever they want. I sure they can come up with something appropriate.:p

As far as holding a U.S. passport, he lost the privilege to be a citizen of the U.S.

 

[spanky250]

Originally posted by Jonala
As far as holding a U.S. passport, he lost the privilege to be a citizen of the U.S.

One of the privileges of being a US citizen is that no one, even if they are a criminal or a traitor, can have their citizenship taken away.

 

[MX265]

Originally posted by JeffK
'I am an American.'

I can't believe this littler f*&^er has the balls to even say those words!!! Does he really consider himself to still be a citizen of our country???? I say we bury him up to his head in my front yard and let me get out my John Deere!!!!!! Brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrkachunkrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr .. End of story.

Jeff

Dude, That's twisted! :eek:

I like it! :p I'll come help dig the hole!

 

[keith500r]

The really sad thing is that piece of @#!$ IS going to get treated better than he deserves just because his mom happened to be on american soil when she dropped her load of trash.

 

[JPIVEY]

Check this out, enough said

http://www.lucianne.com/main.asp

 

[someday]

How about we turn him over to the NYPD and/or NYFD.

 

[JPIVEY]

Originally posted by someday
How about we turn him over to the NYPD and/or NYFD.

One problem

They would be the first ones to save his life, no matter what he has done :(

That's just the way they are

 

[Hucker]

Send him over here.

 

[Rumpelstiltskin]

Hmmm. Citizenship cannot be taken away but I think it can be renounced. If he renounced it then he should be treated as a prisoner of war but obviously he hasn't done that 'cause he stated that he's an American. Therefore what he's done is treason. He incriminated himself. Baaad move.

 

[Jonala]

Originally posted by spanky250
One of the privileges of being a US citizen is that no one, even if they are a criminal or a traitor, can have their citizenship taken away.

Sparky,

This paragraph is in the U.S passport, pg 3,

LOSS OF NATIONALITY. You may lose your U.S. nationality by being naturalized in, or by taking an oath or making the decalaration of allegiance
to, a foreign state, or by serving in the armed forces or accepting employment under the goverment, of a foreign state, or by making a formal renunciation of nationality either in the United States or before a diplomatic or consular officer of the United States while aboard. For detailed information consult the nearest American embassy or consulate.

I heard about this while listening to Rush Limbaugh this morning. A caller pointed out the paragraph.

So it looks like the punk is in deep doo doo.

 

[spanky250]

Originally posted by Jonala
This paragraph is in the U.S passport, pg 3,

LOSS OF NATIONALITY. You may lose your U.S. nationality by serving in the armed forces or accepting employment under the goverment of a foreign state,

Whoops! Looks like he just might not be an American now after all :) ! That was a good bit of info, Jonala!;)

See my signature line? That sure applies to this moron!

 

[MxKid512]

Send him over here

If I was one of the people escorting him back, he wouldn't make it back.

 

[Jaybird]

It's absolutely clear that the fella renounced his citiizenship when he raised his gun with the taliban. And, btw...you CAN be hung for war crimes without being an American.
I say we also arrest his parents for allowing him to go to train with Al Qeada.
Wanton endagerment at the very least.

 

[Old CR goat]

Originally posted by Jaybird

I say we also arrest his parents for allowing him to go to train with Al Qeada.
Wanton endagerment at the very least.

Hmmmmmmmm, you're not serious, are you??:think